Blog

A volunteer coordinator recently shared her situation online. She manages 200 volunteers at a large nonprofit. Some departments track their volunteers in Google Calendar. Some use their volunteer management software. Some use paper sign-in sheets. And some don't track at all.

She thinks about the inbox "all the time."

This isn't unusual. In fact, it's the norm for most volunteer managers I speak to.

The Real Problem Isn't the Tools

Most organisations have perfectly good software sitting unused or half-used. The problem isn't finding the right tool - it's getting everyone to actually use it consistently.

When I ask volunteer coordinators what they'd change, the answer is almost never "I need better software." It's usually something like:

• "I need the youth team to stop using their own spreadsheet"
• "I need the events team to actually log volunteer hours"
• "I need people to check the system before calling me to ask who's available"

The Hidden Costs

Scattered data creates costs that don't show up on any budget:

• Time spent being the "human glue" - reconciling different sources, chasing updates, answering questions you shouldn't need to answer
• Missed opportunities - you can't spot patterns or plan ahead when data is fragmented
• Volunteer frustration - they have to re-enter information, or worse, feel forgotten because their contributions aren't tracked
• Your sanity - carrying the mental load of knowing where everything is because no one else does

What Actually Works

The coordinators who break free from this chaos usually do three things:

1. Pick ONE system and commit - Even if it's not perfect. Consistency beats features.

2. Make it easier than the alternative - If signing in on paper is quicker than the app, paper wins every time. The new way has to be genuinely simpler.

3. Start with one team - Don't try to change everyone at once. Get one department using it properly, show the results, let success spread.

The Question to Ask

If you're drowning in scattered data, ask yourself: What's the ONE thing that causes me the most daily friction?

Not the biggest strategic problem. Not the thing that would look best on a grant report. The thing that interrupts your day, every day.

Fix that first. Everything else gets easier once you've proven change is possible.

That's millions fewer people helping charities (NCVO Almanac 2024).

The data shows why people don't start: out-of-pocket worries, time pressures, unclear expectations.

But what about the ones who sign up and then disappear?

In my experience running volunteer programmes for 13 years, it's friction:

• Confusing sign-up processes
• Weeks of silence during onboarding
• No visibility on what happens next

The charities keeping their volunteers aren't bigger or better-funded. They make it easy to stay.

Clear next steps. Quick responses. Self-service where possible.

If your volunteer coordinator is drowning in admin, that's fixable.

In deprived areas, this rises even higher (NCVO Almanac 2024).

That's a fixable problem.

Most charities have expense policies. But they're buried in a PDF somewhere, mentioned briefly during induction, then forgotten.

Fix: Put it on your volunteer recruitment page. Before the sign-up form.

"We reimburse travel up to £X" "Lunch provided on full-day shifts" "No volunteer should ever be out of pocket"

Remove the doubt before it stops someone signing up.

One line of text. Zero cost. Potentially dozens more volunteers.

Kolb's experiential learning theory identifies four types:

Doers - Want to jump in and try things. Hate sitting through presentations.

Watchers - Need to observe first. Prefer shadowing someone experienced.

Thinkers - Want to understand the theory. Give them the manual.

Feelers - Learn through discussion. Need to talk it through.

Most volunteer training is a presentation followed by "any questions?"

That works for Thinkers. Everyone else switches off.

Try this instead:

• Pair new volunteers with experienced ones (Watchers)
• Let people try tasks with supervision (Doers)
• Create discussion groups (Feelers)
• Have documentation available for reference (Thinkers)

Same content. Four different ways in.

Your training completion rates will thank you.

I spent 13 years volunteering with Derby Kids Camp. 200+ volunteers every summer. And every year, the admin was chaos.

Spreadsheets everywhere. Email chains nobody could follow. DBS certificates in a folder someone might have access to.

I'm a developer, so I wrote code. 10,000+ lines of Google Apps Script. Automated emails. Form validation. Dashboard reports.

It helped. But it was held together with string and prayers.

Then I built a proper volunteer portal:

• Online applications that validate before submission
• DBS tracking with automatic reminders
• Self-service profiles
• Session signups without email chains

100+ volunteers signed up for 2026 before we even started recruiting.

Every charity running on spreadsheets is fighting the same battles.

Beyond Spreadsheets exists because I've lived it.